🪲 Potential bug with Rollup fields in portfolio - not showing number/formula fields available in projects

As of late, the past few days, I noticed that when creating a rollup field in the portfolio, it does not show (all) the available number / formula fields that are within the projects of the portfolio, as it definitely used to. Instead, in the ‘Inputs’ list, it only lists the number fields available within the portfolio, rather than the number fields in the projects within the portfolio.

I have also noticed when I go into roll up fields that were created in the past, that the field used in the rollup formula is marked red, as if it does not exist, like this:


However, the roll up formula within the portfolio works absolutely fine.
The problem is creating new roll up fields in the portfolio.

This has also been noted by another user here.

@Forum-team can you kindly escalate.
Adding @pforumleader and @ambforumleader for visibility and added confirmation.

Thanks!

6 Likes

Hey @Richard_Sather :wave:
We noticed the same here (with @Cyril-iDO ) - Definitely a glitch :slightly_smiling_face:

A temporary workaround:

Meanwhile, getting a fix, we found a tip : add the field to your portfolio first, and then it becomes available for a roll-up. :person_shrugging:

6 Likes

Ah that’s a good workaround, indeed, @Arthur_BEGOU :+1:
Hopefully temporary… :sweat_smile:

2 Likes

Thanks, this works :slight_smile:

2 Likes

Hi @Richard_Sather

Thank you for reporting this. I’ve escalated it to our team and will make sure to share any updates I receive along the way!

Thanks for the workaround, @Arthur_BEGOU!

3 Likes

Thanks, @Julio_V , much appreciated! :+1:

Inside of Red # is like [[$12094**********]]. So I guess rollup() can reach out a custom field.
After making a rollup custom field, We can remove a custom field from a portfolio.then it work well.
But this is inconvenient. I hope it’s temporary, too.

1 Like

Hi,

I am dealing with a similar issue, one of my rollup fields that is pre-existing is showing as follows

There is tons of data in these projects and thus effort so it should be populating numbers and even if there was no effort tracked in the project it should still populate as zero, but the field is just empty.

Welcome @Courtney_Loring , yes! I have noticed this in my space and in the spaces of client’s that I consult - it’s seems the roll formula fields in Portfolios are going through some turmoil these days!

@Forum-team , could you kindly escalate this to the team and add it to the English Forum > Critical Bugs category please?

1 Like

Any updates on this? I’m having a similar issue. I’ve got a series of rollup fields within my portfolio for budget tracking and work progress tracking. All were working correctly 30 minutes ago and then all of a sudden they all stopped working and gave me the hazard sign.
image

I found @Richard_Sather 's post about the potential bug, but in my case the project value is not a seemingly broken link.

I’ve hard closed Asana desktop and opened Asana via web browser and the fields still are still not working. Help please!

Ya same for me too, its a bug. Hope Asana will resolve this.

1 Like

We have the same issue on our side, and the previous workaround shared by @Arthur_BEGOU doesn’t seem to work anymore. Any help Asana? :slight_smile:

3 Likes

@Julio_V, @Richard_Sather,

Today in a client’s portfolio we see these red icons by two custom fields that involve rollups and they’re not rolling up properly:

Last I had checked several weeks ago, these were working fine and no one had changed them.

I tried renaming them and creating new replacements from scratch and they two show the red icon.

These are fields that correspond to Step 7 in @Tetsuo_Kawakami’s:

The field (one of them; they’re similar) is defined like this:

Is this the same bug or related to the bug? @Julio_V, could you please escalate? This is really holding up my client, and it worked fine the last we had checked.

Also, one more probably less critical, separate but potentially related issue: The very same custom field added to a project and added to a portfolio appears differently.

Here’s what it looks like in the project note the presence of “Due date”:

And here’s what it looks like in the portfolio (note the absence of “Due date”:

Maybe just a display bug?

Thanks,

Larry

1 Like

Hey @lpb , for what it’s worth, it appears that the red triangles and the lack of displaying the formula’s result is simply a display issue. The formula is actually performing in the background as I can see in the ‘All activity’ tab of a task and it can even trigger rules that use the When # Number value is changed, as per below example. (formula field ‘% Progress’ being updated, then rule being triggered to change the progress bars)

I should mention that I have this issue in my legacy Phoenix space but not in my new Phoenix on the new/existing plan. Could that be it? Issue is only on legacy plans?

Not sure about the display issue you are seeing regarding Due date input within the formula, it could be linked.

Hi everyone, thanks for your report! It looks like we had two different issues:

  1. Available project number/formula fields not showing up in the portfolio: This issue should be fixed now. Let me know if you’re still having any trouble.
  2. Display issue with rollups: Our Developers confirmed that a fix was deployed yesterday evening (PT time). The issue should be resolved in most rollup formulas. A few might still be broken, but they’re investigating to ensure everything is fixed. If you continue to see any issues, please don’t hesitate to let us know.

@lpb, if the custom field issue is still happening, it could be a separate issue worth investigating.

3 Likes

Good news!!

1 Like

@Vanessa_N Thank you for the update. My portfolio-level rollup formulas are now working correctly! I appreciate the fast response by the development team.

FWIW, the reports in my portfolio Dashboard tab were still functioning properly even though the values themselves were not displaying the in portfolio List tab. Just some additional context for the dev team.

@Richard_Sather thank you for escalating this issue to get it investigated!

3 Likes

The deployed fix worked for our problem too–thanks!

The only remaining issue for us is the minor missing “Due date” in the portfolio edit field as I showed in my earlier post, but it’s just a minor visual thing.

Thanks!!

2 Likes

A post was split to a new topic: Custom field added to a project and added to a portfolio appears differently