Asana Link in Outlook Opening as New Outlook Windows

Hello!

I’m running into a strange issue–when I open an Asana link in the Outlook desktop app, the link opens an Asana window, but grouped with the Outlook windows. So it’s not opening in the Asana app or even the Asana web version.

Is there a way to make the links open in the Asana app? I do have the toggle turned on to open links in the desktop app, so I’m not sure what else to do
image

Any help would be appreciated

thanks!
Margaret

And here’s a view of my settings: