"Task is moved to a section" triggers even if task is moved outside of a section

Hi,

If you create a rule with this trigger

you’ll notice that if fires if:

  • the task is placed in the project, outside of any section
  • the task is moved outside of a section

To me, this is a bug. And because a rule in a bundle doesn’t have the condition “section is not undefined” I am stuck :sweat_smile:

1 Like

@Joanna_Colgan I hope this is a bug, but I am afraid Asana will consider this to be expected behaviour…

Voted! Regardless whether it’s classified one way or another, the root cause is that implementing minimal options may be a slight UI simplicity improvement but more importantly is a complete dead end for your workflow when you need it.

Like coding defensively, it’s good to design defensively.

Thanks,

Larry

1 Like

@Joanna_Colgan were you able to raise this one with the team?

Hey @Bastien_Siebman , sorry, yes! I actually didn’t have to flag it as it’s already been reported by someone else. It’s a part of a bigger bug which is being investigated. We are hoping to see some solution by the end of April.

Hi,

Any news on that bug? Thanks

@Stefan_Kirilov I wanted to double check if that has been seen by your team. Thanks

@Stefan_Kirilov are you the right person to check in with?

@Emily_Roman who should I ping regarding this?

Hi Bastien, apologies for the delay here! I’m checking the status of this escalation internally and I will share an update soon :folded_hands:

1 Like

Thanks @Emily_Roman , any news?

Hi @Bastien_Siebman, I just got an update from our product team, and what you’re experiencing is actually how the feature is currently designed to work.

Because unassigned tasks automatically live in a project’s default “Untitled Section,” a rule set to trigger on “any section” views placing a task there as a move. However, if you want to tighten this up, you can configure the rule’s trigger to look for a specific section instead. That way, it will only fire for deliberate moves into that exact spot.

That being said, we totally get how this behavior can be confusing. I’ve shared your experience directly with our product team as feedback so we can look into making this more intuitive in future updates.

I’d like to trigger for “no section” then or “untitled section” but it doesn’t exist. Disappointing. Thanks anyway!