Firm Wide End of Year Review Process?

I’m currently evaluating whether Asana can support a full Employee:Manager End-of-Year Review process across our firm and would appreciate advice from anyone who has implemented something similar. I was inspired by Asana’s Employee Performance Review template but am trying to determine whether something similar can be scaled across an entire organization while maintaining proper privacy controls.

Our desired workflow looks something like this:

Step 1 Employees complete:

  • Self-Assessment Form
  • (Potentially) other forms for goal setting, stakeholder feedback, etc

Step 2 Managers review submissions.

Step 3 Managers complete a Year-End Review.

Key Requirement: Confidentiality

This is where I’m unsure of the best approach.

Ideally:

  • Employees can only see their own submissions.
  • Managers can only see review information for their direct reports.
  • HR has visibility across all reviews.
  • Managers should not be able to see review content belonging to other managers’ teams.

We have multiple teams and reporting structures, so whatever is implemented would need to scale beyond a small pilot.

I’m curious if anyone here has successfully built:

  • Annual review processes
  • Mid-year review processes
  • Employee goal-setting workflows
  • Manager evaluation workflows

using Asana Forms, Rules, Projects, Portfolios, or another configuration.

Some specific questions:

  1. How did you structure projects and permissions?
  2. Did you use one centralized review project or separate manager-specific projects?
  3. How did you maintain confidentiality?
  4. Did reporting become difficult as participation increased?
  5. Is Asana the right tool for this use case, or did you ultimately move part of the process outside of Asana?

Would love to hear how others approached this and what lessons you learned along the way.

@mk1179,

I’ve built several related workflows and prototyped one quite similar.

Asana has all the building blocks to create a tailored workflow likely satisfying your needs, and the access rights/permisions and scaling concerns are not an issue.

But recognize that there are apps dedicated to doing just this alone, or this as part of a related suite. Asana isn’t that; it’s a toolset where you can build your own (using all the features you mentioned and more; Templates just scratch the surface), with both pros and cons.

I advise you take a very deep dive into Asana, or work with someone (me or another Partner!) to ask the right questions about goals, musts, and wants, and then proceed as soon as that’s understood to a prototype, then iterate. This is a collaborative, interactive process that would be irresponsible (I believe) to try to do in much more detail in a Forum like this.

2 Likes